Replacement Facts

[Christopher Shilts]

I wrote an article about the replacement of White people in America.

[Guest]

What about all the times white people destroyed the things minorities built?

The Tulsa race massacre took place on May 31 and June 1, 1921, when mobs of white residents, some of whom had been deputized and given weapons by city officials, attacked black residents and destroyed homes and businesses of the Greenwood District in Tulsa, Oklahoma, U.S. Alternatively known as the Tulsa race riot or the Black Wall Street massacre, the event is considered one of "the single worst incident[s] of racial violence in American history", and is believed to be one of the deadliest terrorist attacks in the history of the United States. The attackers burned and destroyed more than 35 square blocks of the neighborhood – at the time one of the wealthiest black communities in the United States, known as "Black Wall Street".

If you're going to talk about skin color and human progress you NEED to show how the two are linked. You could just as easily say the world was built by right-handed people.

[Christopher Shilts]

You're engaging in whataboutism. That's ok, I do it too more often than I should. Whatever happened a hundred years ago doesn't invalidate the facts I put forth about what's happening now.

As for the Tulsa race war, I've heard a very different version. It started with an armed altercation between whites and blacks outside of the courthouse, in which 10 white men and 2 black men lay dead or dying. After that both sides went crazy. Gregory Hood as an extensive writeup on this.

President Biden mentioned the black Mount Zion Baptist Church, which whites burned. He didn’t mention that blacks were shooting from the belfry. White civilians, some “deputized,” used the chaos as an excuse to loot and murder. The Guthrie Daily Leader reported at the time that blacks shot at firemen trying to put out the fires and even killed a white woman.

If you're going to talk about skin color and human progress you NEED to show how the two are linked. You could just as easily say the world was built by right-handed people.

Tell me, do you believe the American Republic could have been created by anyone other than Europeans? Do you believe Japan could exist as anything recognizable without the Japanese? I don't believe race and ethnicity are skin deep. They are rooted in biology. You can read some about that here and makeup your own mind.

[SocialistAndFree]

The concept of whiteness is one based on purity and exclusion, destined only to get smaller. I'm not going to dispute the "facts" you put forth about what is happening, i just doubt that your view of why this is happening isnt motivated by racial animus, fear, immasulation, and a bruised ego. Also because, like most right wingers you despise the idea of interracial couples, homosexuals, and women exercising the freedom this great country affords them. (All things that contribute to white genocide)

Tell me, do you believe the American Republic could have been created by anyone other than Europeans? Do you believe Japan could exist as anything recognizable without the Japanese?

...What?

You're the one who says white people "built the world" (whatever that means), not I, so I have no reason to believe that simple ideas like freedom and democracy couldn't exist just because white people were not involved.

Again, you have to show me the specific genetic or environmental abnormality that causes people with white skin to be better "world builders" than literally anyone else who lives in it. Unless you admit that abnormality is money. In which case, the only thing white people built is a tilted capitalist/imperialist system that everyone evidently hates.

[Christopher Shilts]

The concept of whiteness is one based on purity and exclusion, destined only to get smaller.

I have never heard the term "whiteness" used positively toward my people; on the contrary I've only heard it used in attacks against us. But let's try swapping that word out and see if it holds true for other groups.

The concept of blackness is one based on purity and exclusion, destined only to get smaller.
The concept of asianness is one based on purity and exclusion, destined only to get smaller.
The concept of jewishness is one based on purity and exclusion, destined only to get smaller.

Also because, like most right wingers you despise the idea of interracial couples, homosexuals, and women exercising the freedom this great country affords them. (All things that contribute to white genocide)

It seems we are in agreement about the causes, and the outcome. America is increasingly becoming a country devoid of culture. A land where people have no roots, moving from place to place for a paycheck. It used to be that people settled down, raised families, and had a sense of community. In the past, a man could support his wife and children, providing them with a good life. Now men and women are competitors in the job market, and it often takes two parents working full time to support their kids. But it wasn't enough to turn the sexes against each-other, mass immigration is also used to drive down wages, while increasing the cost of living, all to the benefit of the Empire's owners. And by the way, these things don't only affect White people. Blacks, Hispanics, American Indian, and Asian people are all well below replacement fertility levels in this country.

I didn't say we built the world, I said we gave enormous contributions to it. We where the first to invent an enormous number of things that greatly improved the quality of life for people of all races. You seem to be the one with racial animus toward America's European diaspora. You claim we have an abnormality that enables us to use money to create a capitalist / imperialistic system that's hated the world over. You could just as easily levy that claim against the Jews, who have a long history of dominating the financial world, and play an important role in overseeing the American Empire, as touched upon in my Disproportionate Power article. As for Imperialism, I suggest you look into the Mongolian, and Japanese Empires.